Quality Assurance/Quality Improvement Projects
The purpose of this guidance is to assist faculty, students and other personnel on the definition of Research versus Quality Assurance/Quality Improvement (QA/QI). In addition, the guidance provides resources to support the development of QA/QI projects. Whenever there is uncertainty as to whether a project is considered to be research or QA/QI, the project leader should request guidance from the WVSOM Institutional Review Board (IRB). The IRB cannot retroactively approve research.
It is the responsibility of the project leader who initiates a project to determine if it is research or QA/QI. Research projects must comply with specific policies and regulations designed to protect human subjects and privacy rights. However, it may be difficult for a project leader to determine if his or her project is research or QA/QI. Since this determination may have a significant impact on the project design, procedures, and regulatory compliance, the project leader should not hesitate to ask the IRB for guidance. There are serious consequences for not following WVSOM research policies and procedures and federal regulations when conducting research.
This guidance applies to all quality assurance/quality improvement projects undertaken by staff, faculty or students at WVSOM.
How to use this guide
The first section provides definitions for Research and Quality Improvement. The second section provides certain characteristcs typically associated with research and QI projects. Once you review the definitions and characteristics, you should be able to determine the appropriate category for your project. If you determine that the project is similar to both definitions, the project is research.
Section 1. Definitions
What is research?
The federal Common Rule defines research as "a systematic investigation including research development, testing and evaluation designed to develop or contribute to generalizable knowledge".(Source: Code of Federal Regulations 45CFR46.102).
What is Quality Improvement (QI)?
Quality improvement is defined as “a systematic pattern of actions that is constantly optimizing productivity, communication, and value within an organization in order to achieve the aim of measuring the attributes, properties, and characteristics of a product/service in the context of the expectations and needs of customers and users of that product. The Institute of Medicine (IOM) defines quality in health care as a direct correlation between the level of improved health services and the desired health outcomes of individuals and populations. Source: Institute of Medicine
Section 2: Characteristics of Research Projects and Quality Improvement Projects
|Research projects must meet IRB requirements for protection of human subjects. Researchers conducting research must also meet HIPAA and FERPA requirements regarding authorization to use or disclose protected health information.||Quality Improvement projects are not covered by IRB requirements. Members of the workforce are allowed by HIPAA to use protected health information for Quality Improvement projects without patient authorization|
Characteristics of Research:
Characteristics of Quality Improvement:
4. Working on Quality Improvement Projects with Clinics, Hospitals and Other Community Organizations
Contacting a clinical mentor or faculty member and also the health care provider (clinic, hospital, social-service agency administrator) where you will be completing a QA/QI project is a good starting point. Health care providers must all meet Health Information and Patient Protection Act (HIPAA) guidelines and may have specific policy and procedure about accessing health care information at their site. They also will discuss HIPAA training requirements if applicable.
5. Other quality improvement resources
- Carnegie Foundation -Continuous Improvement in Education
- Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)- Quality Improvement in Primary Care
- HHS.gov - Quality improvement activities
Guidance developed by WVSOM Ad Hoc Statewide Campus Research Committee in July 2016; revisions at August 2016 Committee meeting Committee revised document in December 2016.